Home » Amish food, e-bikes and life-changing pretzels: 8 essential stops in Shipshewana, IN

Amish food, e-bikes and life-changing pretzels: 8 essential stops in Shipshewana, IN

by Chrisbutsch

You don’t have to travel to Paris, Milan or Tokyo to immerse yourself in another culture. In Shipshewana, Indiana’s Amish country, I found a surprising blend of timeless traditions, delicious food and unexpected adventures.

I enjoyed a home-cooked Amish feast, took a peaceful buggy ride, and explored scenic countryside along the Pumpkinvine Bike Trail. I browse hundreds of vendors at the Shipshewana Flea Market, sampled creamy farm-fresh milk, and discovered why Ben’s Soft Pretzels has developed such a devoted following. From classic cars to mouthwatering smoked wings, Shipshewana delivers a memorable experience that’s equal parts authentic, charming and delightfully unexpected.

sunflowers at Springfield acres
In 2020, Springfield Acres began growing sunflowers to bring joy to a COVID-stricken world.

A Taste of Shipshewana / Blue Gate Restaurant

If you can only do one thing in Amish country, try to make it a visit to A Taste of Shipshewana. Instead of a traditional restaurant, you’ll visit an actual Amish home just outside of town (a short buggy ride, if you will) where you’ll enjoy a sitdown meal hosted by a charming Amish family. 

The delectable, multi-course meals are served family-style, and you’ll enjoy Amish staples like handmade noodles, gravy, salisbury steak, fresh-whipped potatoes, organic veggies, scrumptious stuffing and more. 

A Taste of Shipshewana typically requires groups of at least 15 people, so if you can’t muster enough company, you can get your Amish food fix at the Blue Gate Restaurant instead. 

amish sampler plate of food
Amish food is heavy and delectable. Don’t come here on a diet! (Photo: Visit Shipshewana)

Shipshewana Buggy Rides

glenn, an amish driver with shipshewana buggy rides
Understandably, most Amish folks politely decline to be photographed. Glenn is the exception.

Your next quintessential Amish stop will be a buggy ride (of course!). 

The aptly named Shipshewana Buggy Rides offers rides of various lengths, from a short 15-minute jaunt for $13/person to a full 4-hour tour including dinner. I’d recommend at least a 30-minute tour ($25/person before tip) so you have plenty of time to enjoy the gentle clop-clopping of your 1-horsepower motor and to chat with your guide. 

Glenn here is one of the few (really only) Amish folks who didn’t mind having his picture taken. When he told his wife he’d gotten a part-time retirement gig driving tourists around, she said “Good! You talk all day, anyways – now you can get paid.”  

two people in buggy
Amish buggies are surprisingly soft and comfy. And yes, they have turn signals.

Stutzman Dairy Farm

cow at stutzman dairy farm
Though this one appears camera-shy, Amish cows are happy and well-cared for.

Stutzman Dairy Farm, also known as Amish Country Dairy, goes by the slogan “Flavors from the land, not the lab.” 

You can see this dedication to freshness and authenticity throughout your guided tour of the farm, from the happy Amish cows to the careful creaming process. See, the Stutzman family produces old-school “cream-top” milk, which retains the tiny fat particles for a creamy, nutrient-dense finish. It’s still pasteurized and perfectly safe, of course (the Stutzmans drink about a liter each per day) – it’s just closer to a milkshake that’s magically healthy somehow. 

Stutzman’s award-winning cream-top milk also comes in numerous delicious flavors including blueberry, blackberry, maple syrup, chocolate, and my personal favorite, root beer. 

stutzman family home in Shipshewana indiana
The Stutzman family property is stunningly beautiful.

Pumpkinvine Bike Trail

biker on pumpkinvine trail
The Pumpkinvine Trail serves as a scenic Amish “highway” between towns.

Considering how heavy Amish food is (and we haven’t even gotten to the Amish pretzels yet), you’ll want to make time for some exercise on your trip to Shipshewana. 

What better way to get it than by hopping on a bike (or e-bike) and hitting the Pumpkinvine Bike Trail? 

Stretching roughly 17 miles from Shipshewana to Elkhart, the Pumpkinvine serves as a major thoroughfare connecting several Amish communities. Along the way you’ll find four public parks, clean public restrooms, snack stops and more, so there’s plenty for both hardcore bikers and young families to enjoy. 

If you’re coming to Shipshewana bike-less, you can rent an e-bike (or an old-school, human-powered bike) at one of several bike shops around town. 

Davis Mercantile & Shipshewana Flea Market

buggy in front of Davis Mercantile
Davis Mercantile, the “Amish mall,” features 21 authentic stores and restaurants. (Photo: Visit Shipshewana)

When it’s time for some shopping (Amishopping?), you have two great options in Shipshewana, which happen to be diametric opposites. 

First, there’s Davis Mercantile. Essentially an indoor Amish shopping mall, the four-story establishment offers 21 stores and restaurants with goodies and gifts you won’t find elsewhere. From handmade leather goods to locally made treats, a puzzle shop to curious boutiques, I found plenty to explore and discover in the mall over the course of roughly two hours. Heck, there’s even a full-sized carousel on the top floor. 

shipshewana Flea market
This photo features just 10ish of the 700+ stalls you can find. (Photo: Visit Shipshewana)

If the weather cooperates – and you have good walking shoes – you can also hit the Shipshewana Flea Market. This booming bazaar is the largest flea market in the entire Midwest region, featuring over 700 vendors across a property larger than 30 football fields. 

Many of the shops are permanent fixtures, too. My favorite discovery was Honest John’s Used Toy Cars. True to his name, I asked John if I could offer him $25 for a rare diecast Mercedes. 

“You can!” he said with a warm grin. “Doesn’t mean it’ll work.” 

The Black Sheep

baked wings at The Black Sheep in Shipshewana
The Black Sheep’s baked wings are some of the best I’ve ever had.

You know those small-town restaurants that are so good that they constantly run out of food before they even close for the day? 

In Shipshewana, that’s The Black Sheep. Founded by two local farmers who didn’t find farming demanding enough on its own (I know I would), The Black Sheep features smoked local meats, homemade sangria, burgers, dogs, green beans with bacon, and my favorite by far, smoked wings. These things just melted off the bone and exploded with flavor, and I honestly can’t recall ever eating a better wing. 

Be sure to call or email them in advance to confirm their hours since they often close up shop when they run out of food or need to tend to the farm!

Blue Gate Music Hall

Blue Gate Music Hall
With “only” 1,500ish seats, there’s not a bad view in the house. 

Blue Gate Music Hall is Shipshewana’s premier music and event hall, and despite being in a town of just 900 people, it attracts some pretty big names. We saw Tyler Hubbard while we were there, and Mannheim Steamroller is coming later this year. 

But even if nothing leaps out at you on the event calendar, it might be worth grabbing some cheap tickets just to experience the venue’s amazing acoustics, comfy seats and classic car collection. 

classic cars at Blue Gate Music Hall
With “only” 1,500ish seats, there’s not a bad view in the house. 

Yep, you read that right; Blue Gate Music Hall features a lineup of classic cars that is free for any ticketholder to enjoy. You can get close enough to a 1917 Packard Twin Six or a 1957 Ford Thunderbird to smell the leather. Bet you weren’t expecting that in the middle of Amish country.

Ben’s Soft Pretzels

Amish pretzel
If this pretzel looks lopsided, it’s because yours truly made it. And it was still the best pretzel I’ve ever had by a country mile. 

Assuming you haven’t consumed enough calories yet, you should definitely pay a visit to Ben’s Soft Pretzels before departing Shipshewana. 

To illustrate just how damn good this pretzel is, Amish baker Ben Miller and his wife originally launched their first pretzel shop in 2008. When they expanded into local stadiums, they got in trouble because the lines were too long. So they opened multiple locations in each venue, but the “problem” persisted. 

What’s so special about this $5 pretzel? Well, just like other Amish food, it’s a culmination of just a handful of ingredients that the Amish have perfected over centuries. Salt, butter, dough. Get the best in the world, and the best pretzel will follow. 

But after just one of these buttery delights, it might be time to hit the Pumpkin Trail again!

Where to Stay in Shipshewana

While there are plenty of beautiful AirBnBs in and around Shipshewana, Blue Gate Garden Inn is the go-to choice for most travelers. 

It’s clean, quiet, and the rooms are impressively upscale for the modest price (~$138 – $250/night). There’s a decent gym, plenty of outdoor seating for wine-o’clock, a pool, an arcade for the kids and a daily Amish breakfast buffet. Plus, it’s centrally located and right next door to the Blue Gate Music Hall. 

For more attractions, hidden gems and planning out your visit, check out visitshipshewana.org. 

– Photos and text by Chris Butsch, staff writer and founder of Your Car Negotiator

You may also like

The Travel 100

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More